Finding Aid to the Ella Sterling Mighels papers, 1870-1934 MS 1470

Finding aid prepared by Processed by California Historical Society staff.
California Historical Society
678 Mission Street
San Francisco, CA, 94105
415-357-1848
reference@calhist.org
2001


Title: Ella Sterling Mighels papers
Date (inclusive): 1870-1934
Collection Number: MS 1470
Creator: Mighels, Ella Sterling, 1853-1934
Contributing Institution: California Historical Society
678 Mission Street
San Francisco, CA, 94105
415-357-1848
reference@calhist.org
Language of Materials: Collection materials are in English.
Physical Description: 13 boxes (6.5 linear feet)
Location: Collection located onsite.
Abstract: Correspondence; diaries (1900-1927), called "soulbooks"; literary manuscripts; four scrapbooks; and miscellaneous papers. The bulk of the collection consists of typescripts and manuscripts of Mighels' writings and stories. Correspondence includes letters to and from her second husband, Philip V. Mighels, an author, mainly about personal matters, including finances, real estate purchases, and literary sales. Many of the letters are from Mrs. Mighels to friends and fellow writers, often identified by first name or nickname only. Includes papers of Ark-adian Brothers and Sisters of California, a cultural and educational group for neighborhood children, established by Mighels in her home; and papers of the California Literature Society, of which Mighels was secretary. Correspondents include Ina Coolbrith, Ann Clark Hart, Clarence M. Hunt, Rockwell D. Hunt, David Starr Jordan, Carleton Kendall, James D. Phelan, Richard E. White, and League of American Pen Women. Also includes a small amount of genealogical material. Diaries include two by Mighel's daughter, Genevieve (Viva) Cummins Doan, chronicling a trip to England (1900-1901). One of the scrapbooks is organized by Mighels' first husband, Adley Cummins (1873) and contains clippings and information about his mother's death.

Information for Researchers

Access

Collection is open for research.

Publication Rights

Copyright has not been assigned to the California Historical Society. All requests for permission to publish or quote from manuscripts must be submitted in writing to the Director of Research Collections. Permission for publication is given on behalf of the California Historical Society as the owner of the physical items and is not intended to include or imply permission of the copyright holder, which must also be obtained by the reader.

Preferred Citation

[Identification of item], Ella Sterling Mighels Collection, MS 1470. California Historical Society, Manuscript Collection.

National Union Catalog of Manuscript Collections Number

NUCMC 82-431

Separated Materials

Photographs, two postcards, and one lantern slide shelved as MSP 1470.
The Postman's Song, with words by Ellas Sterling Cummins, shelved in Sheet Music Collection, Box 6: 1890-1899.

Indexing Terms

The following terms have been used to index the description of this collection in the library's online public access catalog.
Ark-adian Brothers and Sisters of California.
California Literature Society.
Cummins, Adley Hooks
Doan, Genevieve (Viva) Cummins
Mighels, Philip V.
American fiction--Women authors
Diaries.
Scrapbooks.
Women authors, American--California
Women authors, American--California--Correspondence
Women Authors, American--California--Diaries

Index to Correspondence

  • California Literature Society
    • 1919 May 28
    • 1926 March 22
  • Coolbrith, Ina Donna, 1842-1928
    • 1913 October 7
    • 1914 September 21
    • 1914 September 23
    • 1914 October 6
    • 1914 October 11
    • 1916 January 25
    • 1916 March 1
    • 1916 March 7
    • 1916 March 8
    • 1915 July 17
    • 1916 December 2
    • 1916 December 7
    • 1916 December 19
    • 1917 January 13
    • 1917 January 24
    • 1917 March 16
    • 1917 December 19
    • 1918 January
    • 1918 May 7
    • 1928 March 12
  • Fischer, Frank
    • 1928 April 21
  • Hart, Ann Clark
    • 1921 May 14
    • 1921 August 8
    • 1926 May 6
  • Hearst, Phoebe Apperson
    • 1916 July 24
  • Jordan, David Starr, 1851-1931
    • 1914 December 29
    • 1924 July 22
    • 1924 December 10
  • Kendall, Carleton
    • 1928 March 12
  • Mighels, Philip Verril
    • 1911 October 16
    • 1912 February 14
    • 1928 March 12
  • Older, Fremont
    • undated
  • Phelan, James Duval, 1861-1930
    • 1914 January 21
    • 1917 September 1
    • 1920 October 19
    • 1925 August 17
    • 1928 January 1
    • 1928 January 13
    • 1928 June 13
  • Race discrimination
    • 1911 June 25
    • 1916 January 15
    • 1920 November 25
    • 1920 November 29
    • 1924 February 7
    • 1926 October 3
    • 1927 January 15
    • 1927 March 28
    • 1928 April 21
  • Sterling, George
    • 1916 November 26
  • Tilden, Douglas
    • undated
  • Wagner, Harr
    • 1926 April 18
    • 1932 April 15
  • Women - Suffrage
    • 1906 July 18
    • 1917 September 1
    • 1917 October 16
    • 1920 June 21
    • 1928 April 21
    • undated

Administrative Information

Acquisitions

Gift of Edson Adams, Ernestine Adams, and Mrs. Hutchins.

Accruals

No additions are expected.

Processing Information

Processed by CHS staff.

Biography

Ella Sterling Mighels, California pioneer, author and literary historian, was born Ella Sterling Clark in Mormon Island, the first established California gold mining camp, near Sacramento, on May 5, 1853.
Her father, Sterling Benjamin Franklin Clark of Rutland, Vermont, came to California in 1849 and was propertied, prosperous and the Alcalde, or judge, of the Sacramento district within three years. He then returned east to marry and bring his bride, the former Rachel Hepburn Mitchell, to California. Rachel was a native of Philadelphia and the daughter of John Mitchell, the County Superintendent of Schools.
Several months before Ella's birth, as her parents arrived in California, her father died. Rachel opened the first school in the Sacramento area and, in 1854, married Dudley H. Haskell, a 49er and member of the first Nevada Legislature (1864).
The Haskells, including Ella's baby stepbrother and stepsisters, lived in Sacramento until 1863 when Rachel and the children moved to Pennsylvania. Three years later the Haskell family reunited and moved to Aurora (or Esmeralda), Nevada, a Comstock boom town. They maintained a toll road during the waning years of the town and Mr. Haskell was pleased to accept the position of railroad land agent in Reno, offered by Leland Stanford in 1869. The Haskell family moved back to Sacramento where Ella remained until her marriage to Adley H. Cummins in 1872.
Adley Cummins, a native of Chester County, Pennsylvania, came to California in 1869 at the age of nineteen and worked for several years for the railroad. Cummins was a well known philologist, author, lecturer and lawyer. He was the love of Ella's life and the father of her only child, a daughter named Genevieve or Viva, born October 17, 1875. The Cummins family traveled a great deal but maintained a base in the San Francisco Bay Area. In 1889, at the age of thirty-nine, Adley died of heart disease.
Ella had spent much of her life writing articles and short stories, but now, following her great loss, she began to work on a mammoth project, a compendium of early California journalism and literature to be published in 1893 as The Story of the Files. This same year Ella was appointed Lady Commissioner from San Francisco to the Columbian Exposition.
During the writing of The Story, Ella met Philip Verril Mighels, a native of Carson City, Nevada, a lawyer by education and a newspaper artist and writer by trade. They were married in 1896 and moved to London the same year.
In 1901, following the death of Ella's mother, the Mighels family returned to the United States and lived in New York for several years. Here Ella claims to have persuaded her husband to develop his literary skills. Regardless of her influence, Philip became an acclaimed novelist and playwright while he continued to work for newspapers.
Viva Cummins married Augustus Doan in 1896 and spent several years at music school in London on a scholarship provided by Phoebe Hearst. Viva performed as a “Race Impersonator”, singing and dancing in the style of the Native American, Hungarian, Hindu, etc.
Both Viva and Dudley Haskell died in 1905 and two years later Ella returned to California, never to leave her San Francisco home again. She and her husband grew apart in temperament and career aspirations, and Ella divorced him in 1910. Philip died in 1911 as a result of a hunting accident.
During the later part of her life, Ella developed a philosophy called “Ark-adianism”, which reflected her pioneer California and Victorian up-bringing. She described Ark-adianism as, “...a system of philosophy which substitutes normal things for abnormal things in every department of life especially the home life” (letter, 5/19/11).
Ella believed in kindness and humanism, in Church and the Bible, in the purity of the white race, in democracy and freedom, and in the benign dominance of men. She was opposed to moral corruption, “chaos and socialism”, Jewish, Japanese and Black immigration, scientific education and the medical profession.
She believed that children, who were in a conspiracy against authority, should be kept disciplined, innocent and happy. She identified a child's seven friends--work, bread, music, art, letters, invention and common sense--and believed that women should dedicate their lives to the upbringing of children as their mothers had before them. She did not believe in women's suffrage (“They have no caution, no principles, when it comes to voting”, letter, 9/1/17), and she was opposed to birth control (“Parents who lend themselves to exercising `Birth Control' are punished for interferring with Nature and they fall victim to epilepsy, nervous prostration, insanity or lingering death”, letter, 12/28/16).
Children loomed large in Ella's life, and in her later years she developed a neighborhood literary program for the moral uplift of young people which she named the “Ark-adian Brothers and Sisters”. Her program included providing “books one ought to read”, and organizing both annual burnings of “bad” books and “potlatches” or gift giving parties. The motto of her little club was “Thou shalt keep the peace” and she stressed the importance of innocence and happiness among her young neighbors.
In order to bring the children of her club into association with “nice friends”, Ella organized the California Literature Society which met monthly at the home of Ina Coolbrith, California'a first poet laureate, until 1916, and then met elsewhere until Ella's death.
As did other writers of her time, Ella identified herself with the early California pioneer spirit, writing constantly, if not brilliantly, about the kind of pioneer Californians who had rocked her “to sleep in a goldrocker once used to wash the pay dust from the American river sands” (O'Brien, 1946).
Ella tended to focus more on self-identified “fairy tales” and the mythology of the gold rush than on historical fiction. Yet whe also wrote as a chronicler of early California literary history and was named “first historian of literary California” by the state legislature in 1919.
Ella's literary career began at the age of ten, when the Aurora Union published a fairy story she had written, and she was the first native Californian to publish a novel, Little Mountain Princess, in 1880. Her best known later works were The Full Glory of Diantha (1909), Literary California (1918), an expansion of The Story of the Files; and The Story of a Forty-Niner's Daughter (1934). She also authored a play, Society and Babe Robinson (1914) and persuaded James Phelan to publish her father's travel diary, How Many Miles From St. Jo? (1929).
Ella occasionally wrote on other subjects of interest to her, such as the importance of maintaining the purity of the white race (“The Fairy Tale of the White Man”) and the benign dominance of men (“The Mid-Victorian Man”). Most of her works on these other subjects were in the form of fairy tales or common sense discussions and only a small number were published.
Ella died in 1934 following the publication of The Story of a Forty-Niner's Daughter, written under the pen name of Aurora Esmeralda. Her autobiography reflected Ella's life long belief that “she was destined to be the link between the Gold Rush days and the 20th century's brave new world” (O'Brien, 1946).
References:
Cummins, Ella Sterling, The Story of the Files. World's Fair Commission of California, Columbian Exposition, 1893.
Esmeralda, Aurora (Ella Sterling Mighels), The Story of a Forty-Niner's Daughter. San Francisco: Harr Wagner Publishing, 1934.
Gudde, Erwin G., California Gold Camps. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1975.
O'Brien, Robert, “Riptides”, San Francisco Chronicle, December 18, 1946.
Who's Who of Literary America, 1927.

Scope and Content

The Ella Sterling Mighels collection consists of correspondence, diaries, genealogical material, writing and stories, miscellaneous material and scrap-books.
The correspondence includes personal letters between Ella and her family, particularly her second husband, and other personal and business letters. Some of her letters to others are handwritten or typed, but many are carbon copies of typed letters.
Ella's correspondence with Philip Mighels reflect and describe the course of her second marriage, which ended in divorce in 1910.
Ella's other correspondence was generally with authors, publishers, newspaper editors and politicians, including Ina Coolbrith, James Phelan, David Starr Jordan, Phoebe Hearst, George Sterling, Ann Clark Hart, Harr Wagner, Fremont Older, Douglas Tilden, Frank Fischer and Carleton Kendall.
She regularly discusses her current literary projects, complaining about her difficulties and frustrations with writing and publishing, and assigning her works great social and moral value.
She also draws from her background in the California gold rush to discuss her childhood and the history of her family. She often laments the passage of the pioneer mothers and fathers, their stories, their customs and their memories, and she writes about being involved in many pioneer remembrance displays, including the erection of a statue of the “Pioneer Mother”.
Throughout much of her correspondence are discussions of her personal philosophy “Ark-adianism”, particularly as it concerns women, the family and the raising and education of children. Her correspondence also contains references to her neighborhood neophytes, known as the “Ark-adian Brothers and Sisters”, including several men and women who continued to inform her of their lives and literary adventures long after they had left her fold.
The diaries include two written by Ella's dauthter, Genevieve (Viva) Cummins Doan, chronicling her trip to England (1900-1901). They contain descriptions of her boat trip, daily activities, studies, entertainment and dance productions as a “Race Impersonator”.
Ella also contributed a number of diaries or “Soulbooks”, which chronicle her thoughts, concerns, writing and daily activities between 1904 and 1927. The “Soulbooks” contain little sayings (i.e., “Marriage is a custom invented by man for the protection of woman and the conservation of the family”); copies of her published letters to editors, articles and short stories; letters received and written; notes to herself (i.e., “Doe the next thyngge”); hand-bills, reviews, articles and ephemera concerning her published works and her activities; material concerning the construction of a “Pioneer Mothers” statue; descriptions of family and friends such as Adley Cummins, Philip Mighels, Ina Coolbrith and the Ark-adian Brothers and Sisters; material concerning the California Literature Society and her title confirmation as “first historian of literary California”; discussions of her current literary works and publishing problems, her health and financial concerns.
The genealogical material includes two family trees of the Mighels family, questions regarding the Clark family and “The Book of the House of Mitchell”, which contains a genealogy of the Mitchell, Clark and Haskell families. In “The Book”, Ella states, “The descendents of William Mitchell[UNK]her great-grandfather[UNK]...have produced a race with such marked characteristics that they are a source of constant inquiry to themselves and to others.”
The writing and stories include typed and handwritten drafts of numerous lectures, stories, fairy tales, poems, plays and novels by Ella, such as “Wawona”, “The Deathless Romance of Herman and Thusnelda”, “The Seven Faithful Fairies”, “Society and Babe Robinson”, “Killarg and Thotha”, “Seven Men of Borealis”, “The Full Glory of Diantha”, and “Ar Vyvah”, as well as “thoughts and scribblings” on miscellaneous subjects such as Ark-adian education.
The miscellaneous material includes unorganized writing by others, particularly Ella's first husband, Adley Cummins; ephermera, reprints of Ella's articles, newspaper clippings, and material relating to the California Literature Society and the Ark-adian Brothers and Sisters.
The scrapbooks include a scrapbook organized by Adley Cummins (1873), containing newspaper clippings and information about the death of his mother.
Several scrapbooks organized by Ella are also included (1893-1930). These contain published articles by Ella concerning various subjects, particularly her travels to Alaska, London and the Chicago World's Fair of 1894; reviews of her works, particularly “The Full Glory of Diantha”; newspaper clippings concerning her divorce from Philip Mighels, and her other activities; and photographs, letters and ephemera.
Twenty one photographs, two postcards and one lantern slide were transferred to California Historical Society's Photograph Collection. They include one postcard displaying the “Original idea of the `Children's Statue of the Pioneer Mother”', and one of the statue “The Nations of the West” from the Panama Pacific International Exposition. They also include two photographs of a mother an children (posing for the Pioneer Mother statue), one of Ella with her family (?), one of “Hal Haskell, Auburndale, Mass.”, two of John Mitchell (?), two of Ella, two of Genevieve (Viva) Cummins, one of James Phelan, one of a “Group of Citizens of Aurora, California (now Aurora, Nev.) taken 1865”, and nine of unknown individuals and places. Also included is one lantern slide of an unknown individual.

Arrangement

Arranged into six series:
Series 1: Correspondence
Series 2: Diaries
Series 3: Genealogical Material
Series 4: Writing and Stories
Series 5: Miscellaneous Material
Series 6: Scrapbooks

 

Series 1 Correspondence 1870-1934

Physical Description: 16 folders

Arrangement

Arranged chronologically.

Scope and Contents

Consists of personal and professional correspondence, in reference to her own writings, and relating to her duties as California Literary Historian, and as a member of various groups such as the California Literature Society and the Ark-adian Brothers and Sisters. Notable correspondants include Ina Coolbrith, Phoebe Apperson Hearst, James Phelan, and various State officials.
Box 1, Folder 1

1870-1904

Box 1, Folder 2

1905-1909

Box 1, Folder 3

1910-1914

Box 1, Folder 4

1915-1917

Box 1, Folder 5

1918-1919

Box 1, Folder 6

1920-1922

Box 1, Folder 7

1923-1924

Box 1, Folder 8

1925

Box 2, Folder 9

1926

Box 2, Folder 10

1927

Box 2, Folder 11

1928-1929

Box 2, Folder 12

1930-1931

Box 2, Folder 13

1932

Box 2, Folder 14

1933-1934

Box 2, Folder 15-16

undated

 

Series 2 Diaries 1900-1927

Physical Description: 17 folders

Arrangement

Arranged chronologically.

Scope and Contents

Diaries, notebooks, and logbooks, including two diaries belonging to Genevieve Cummins Doan, and Ella Sterling Mighel's "Soulbooks".
Box 3, Folder 17

Diary, Genevieve Cummins Doan 1900 July-1901 January

Box 3, Folder 18

Diary, Genevieve Cummins Doan 1901 February-July

Box 3, Folder 19

Notebook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1904

Box 3, Folder 20

Logbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1907-1908

Box 3, Folder 21

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1910 March 21-1911 January 17

Box 3, Folder 22

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1912 January 18-March 27

Box 3, Folder 23

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1912 May 10-1913 March 3

Box 3, Folder 24

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1913 March 12-November 15

Box 3, Folder 25

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1913 November 28-1915 December 16

Box 4, Folder 26

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1915 December 21-1917 November 30

Box 4, Folder 27

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1917 December 6-1919 December28

Box 4, Folder 28

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1920 January 1-1921 February 5

Box 4, Folder 29

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1921 February 23-1924 March 2

Box 4, Folder 30

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1924 March 25-1925 October 28

Box 5, Folder 31

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1925 November 13-1926 November 4

Box 5, Folder 32

Soulbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1926 November 11-1927 August 25

Box 5, Folder 33

Address book undated

 

Series 3 Genealogical Material undated

Physical Description: 1 folder

Arrangement

Creator's own arrangement.

Scope and Contents

One notebook and a few loose papers containing clippings, anecdotes, keepsakes, and sketches of the family tree.
Box 5, Folder 34

Family tree, Mighels family; “The Book of the House of Mitchell” undated

 

Series 4 Writing and Stories 1897-1914, undated

Physical Description: 49 folders

Arrangement

Arranged by story.

Scope and Contents

Manuscripts and typescripts of stories and fairy tales. Includes poetry, lectures and editorial writing.
Box 6, Folder 35

Fairy tales undated

Box 6, Folder 36

Wawona undated

Box 6, Folder 37

Followers of the Sun undated

Box 6, Folder 38

The Children of Una Materna 1911

Box 6, Folder 39

The Awakening of Dior and King of the Forest undated

Box 6, Folder 40

The Meadow Elf's Bride undated

Box 6, Folder 41

Sir Galahad versus Tannhauser undated

Box 6, Folder 42

Deathless Romance of Herman and Thusnelda undated

Box 6, Folder 43

The Tourch Bearers 1906

Box 6, Folder 44-45

The Seven Faithful Fairies undated

Box 7, Folder 46-47

Seven Men of Borealis circa 1909-1913

Box 7, Folder 48-50

Miscellaneous stories and writing 1897-1914

Box 7, Folder 51

The Full Glory of Diantha undated

Box 7, Folder 52

The Inscription undated

Box 7, Folder 53

Its Adios to Violetta undated

Box 7, Folder 54

Ar Vyvah undated

Box 8, Folder 55

Streets of Old San Francisco undated

Box 8, Folder 56-63

Society and Babe Robinson undated

Box 9, Folder 64

Silver-Cloud and Diamond-Crown undated

Box 9, Folder 65-67

Daintytree's Quest undated

Box 9, Folder 68-69

Killarg and Thotha undated

Box 9, Folder 70

Ark-adian Education undated

Box 9, Folder 71

Lectures by Ella Sterling Mighels undated

Box 9, Folder 72

Miscellaneous thoughts and scribblings undated

Box 10, Folder 73-82

Miscellaneous writing undated

Box 10, Folder 83

Poetry by Ella Sterling Mighels undated

 

Series 5 Miscellaneous Material 1880-1933

Physical Description: 20 folders

Arrangement

Arranged by subject.

Scope and Contents

Consists of miscellaneous print and manuscript items - programs, invitations, advertisements, and other ephemera relating to Mighels' personal life. Also copies of Senate Weekly Histories proclaiming her appointment as California Literary Historian, literary magazines, a handmade childrens book of nursery stories, fragments of Mighels' writings from printed sources, news clippings, and log books and records of the Ark-adian Library.
Box 11, Folder 84-85

Ephemera 1896-1933

Box 11, Folder 86

Invitations, programs 1901-1933

Box 11, Folder 87

Senate Weekly Histories 1919

Box 11, Folder 88

Pamphlets, reprints 1907-1932

Box 11, Folder 89

Literary magazines undated

Box 11, Folder 90

Mother Goose's Gosling undated

Box 11, Folder 91-92

Reprints 1883-1926

Box 11, Folder 93

Poems by others undated

Box 12, Folder 94-95

Writing by and about Adley Cummins 1880-1918

Box 12, Folder 96

Information about Ella Sterling Mighels' will 1924

Box 12, Folder 97

Newspaper clippings regarding Ella Sterling Mighels 1881-1933

Box 12, Folder 98-99

Miscellaneous clippings 1913-1933

Box 12, Folder 100

Miscellaneous papers of the California Literature Society and the Ark-adian Brothers and Sisters 1922-1932

Box 12, Folder 101-102

Little Ark-adian Library log-books 1910-1917

Box 12, Folder 103

Ark-adian records 1917

 

Series 6 Scrapbooks 1873-1930

Physical Description: 4 folders

Arrangement

Arranged chronologically.

Scope and Contents

Scrapbooks containing writings, newsclippings, letters, and cards.
Box 13, Folder 105

Scrapbook, Adley H. Cummins, Sacramento 1873

Box 13, Folder 106

Scrapbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1893-1912

Box 13, Folder 107

Scrapbook, Ella Sterling Mighels 1917-1930

Box 13, Folder 104

Unknown scrapbook undated